Skip to content 
The crew emptied the compactor and transported the compressed waste to Richmond’s landfill, where it was buried beneath tons of refuse. That explained why no search ever found Nicole’s remains. Her body had been destroyed by machinery within hours of her disappearance. It was the perfect concealment—industrial, efficient, and invisible to investigators who never imagined looking there.
That evening, Calvin gave Vanessa the cross as proof that Nicole was gone. Vanessa asked no questions about how it had been done or where Nicole’s body was. She simply kept the necklace. For her, it was insurance. If Calvin ever tried to implicate her, she possessed a piece of evidence that tied him directly to Nicole’s death.
For six months after the crime, Calvin and Vanessa remained together, bound by their shared secret. But Vanessa gradually began to distance herself. When she left for college in the fall of 1985, she cut off all contact. She ignored Calvin’s calls, never answered his letters, and never acknowledged the relationship again. Calvin’s life deteriorated from there.
He drifted through low-wage jobs, never built a stable future, and by the time of his 2019 arrest was living alone in an aging trailer and working warehouse night shifts. The 2020 trial became a national story. Media coverage focused on the extraordinary way the case had been solved—through evidence hidden for decades in an attorney’s safe. Because the murder occurred in 1984, prosecutors applied the Virginia statutes in effect at that time rather than current law.