Skip to content 
Enslaved women who had observed everything and forgotten nothing. By mid-September, 6 weeks after her son’s birth, Catherine had compiled enough evidence to form a devastating conclusion. She confronted Hannah in the kitchen house, demanding to know how the midwife had reached the conclusion she had whispered in the birthing room.
Hannah explained the birthmark. She described delivering Ruth’s son in 1824, Thomas Whitfield II’s child, by an enslaved woman. She described being loaned to the Blackburn plantation that same year to assist with Sarah’s difficult birth. She described seeing the identical birthmark on both babies. Catherine listened with growing horror.
She asked whether Hannah had told anyone else. The midwife replied that she had not because no one would believe an enslaved woman’s word against white families, and speaking such truths could result in severe punishment or sale. To understand how such a situation could develop and remain hidden for decades, one must understand the complete system that governed Antebellum Virginia Plantation Society.
The region’s economy depended on tobacco cultivation, which in turn depended on enslaved labor. By 1847, Albemarle County’s enslaved population exceeded its white population by a significant margin. Virginia law defined enslaved people as property, not persons with legal rights. An 1806 statute required any enslaved person freed by their owner to leave Virginia within 12 months or be re-enslaved.
An 1831 law prohibited teaching enslaved people to read or write. Enslaved people could not testify in court against white persons, could not own property, could not legally marry, and had no protection against physical or sexual abuse by their owners. Enslaved midwives existed in this system, carrying knowledge that could threaten white families while having no legal power to use that knowledge.
They witnessed births, deaths, illnesses, and the intimate details of family life. They understood biological relationships that official records denied, and they remained silent because the alternative was punishment or death. Hannah had learned midwifery from her mother, who learned from her grandmother, preserving knowledge that stretched back to West Africa.
African-American midwives combined traditional practices with practical experience gained from delivering hundreds of babies. They used herbal remedies to ease labor pain, positioned mothers to facilitate delivery, and dealt with complications using techniques passed through generations. Plantation owners valued enslaved midwives because they were cheaper than white physicians and because they could deliver enslaved babies without requiring payment.
But owners also feared the knowledge these women possessed, understanding implicitly that midwives witnessed truths that undermined the racial and social hierarchies that justified slavery. Catherine Whitfield found herself trapped by the truth Hannah had revealed. If she confronted her husband Thomas with the evidence that they shared a father, the scandal would destroy both families.
Her marriage would be revealed as incestuous. Her son would be born of that incest, and her own legitimacy as Henry Blackburn’s daughter would be questioned. If she remained silent, she would spend the rest of her life living a lie, raising a child born of biological incest, and carrying knowledge that made every moment with her husband feel like a violation.
She could not confide in her mother Martha because asking whether Martha had been unfaithful to Henry Blackburn with Thomas Whitfield II would either confirm the terrible truth or destroy their relationship through the accusation alone. She could not seek guidance from other white women in her social circle because such a revelation would make her family the subject of gossip and ostracism.
The only person who understood her situation was Hannah, an enslaved woman who had no legal standing and whose testimony would never be accepted in any official setting. Catherine’s behavior began to change in ways that concerned her husband and mother-in-law. She became withdrawn, spending long hours alone with the baby. She stopped attending social gatherings at neighboring plantations.
She showed little interest in resuming intimate relations with Thomas, claiming prolonged recovery from childbirth. Thomas attributed these changes to the melancholy that sometimes affected new mothers. Eleanor Whitfield suggested that Catherine needed more rest and perhaps a change of scenery. Neither suspected the truth that was consuming Catherine from within.