Skip to content 
At 7:30 that evening, after the initial celebration had settled and Thomas had returned to entertaining the neighbors, Hannah found herself alone with Catherine for a brief moment. The new mother was holding her son, exhausted but content, when Hannah leaned close and spoke quietly. The words she whispered would haunt Catherine Whitfield for the rest of her life.
Catherine said nothing immediately. She dismissed Hannah’s words as the confused ramblings of an enslaved woman overcome by the intensity of the birthing experience. But over the following days, as she recovered and spent hours holding her newborn son, Catherine began to examine the birthmark more closely. She asked her mother-in-law Eleanor about family features, inquiring whether any Whitfields had distinctive marks.
Eleanor mentioned nothing about the three-spot birthmark. Catherine wrote to her own mother, Martha, in Buckingham County, asking about her childhood and any unusual marks she might have had as an infant. Martha’s response arrived 10 days later. She described a birthmark on Sarah’s left shoulder blade.
Three spots arranged in a triangle which had faded somewhat as she grew, but remained visible. Catherine felt the first stirrings of something that would gradually transform into horrified certainty. Enslaved people at Whitfield Manor had known for decades that Thomas Whitfield II fathered children among the enslaved population.
This was not unusual. Sexual exploitation of enslaved women by white men was endemic throughout the South, creating mixed-race populations that white societies simultaneously acknowledged and refused to recognize legally. What was unusual was that Thomas Whitfield II had apparently also fathered a child with Martha Blackburn, his business associate’s wife.
The enslaved community had whispered about this for years, but such whispers rarely reached white ears, and when they did, they were dismissed as malicious rumors. Hannah had carried this knowledge for 23 years, watching Sarah Blackburn grow up on visits between the plantations, seeing her marry Thomas Whitfield III, and understanding the biological reality that neither the white families nor Sarah herself recognized.
Catherine began her investigation carefully. She examined family papers in Thomas’s study when he was occupied with plantation business. She looked for correspondence between her father, Henry Blackburn, and Thomas Whitfield II. She studied the plantation’s visiting records from 1823. What she discovered confirmed her growing suspicions.
Thomas Whitfield II had spent 3 months at the Blackburn plantation in 1823, supposedly planning a joint tobacco venture that never materialized. During that same period, her mother Martha had been mysteriously absent from social events, claiming illness that lasted several months. Catherine found a letter from Martha to a friend written in late 1823, mentioning a pregnancy that had caused considerable anxiety.
The letter’s tone suggested that Martha had concerns about the pregnancy beyond normal maternal worries, though she did not specify what those concerns were. The investigation Catherine was conducting would uncover truths that plantation society was built to conceal. The evidence she would find came from sources that white families never expected.