Skip to content 
The medical literature did not offer any framework for understanding what she had witnessed. In the fall of 1895, before Garrett’s intervention, Sarah gave birth to her fifth child, who suffered from a cleft palate so severe that it required constant feeding. Her sixth child, born in early 1896, had such abnormal limb development that one of her arms stopped at the elbow and the corresponding leg reached only the middle of the thigh.
Each new birth seemed to bring its share of misfortunes, as if the genetic heritage of the parents combined into countless malformations. In the winter of 1895, after the birth of their fifth child, Sarah was desperate. The midwife, Martha Combmes, noticed that both parents had begun consulting with a neighbor, Elias Burke, a hermit who claimed to have studied ancient mountain remedies passed down from his grandfather, a man he said had cared for children born with health problems. Burke insisted that their ailments were…
It wasn’t blood, but a blocked vitality, a problem that could be solved by rebalancing the moods. She sold Benjamin a rudimentary potion made from crushed lead filings, foxglove leaves, and alcohol, promising him that it would thin his thick blood and heal their unborn child. Benjamin, too sure of himself and too desperate, took it every day for weeks.
Although hesitant, Sarah began taking her dose mixed with molasses after Elias’ wife swore that it restored fertility to the barren women in her family. The tonics burned their throats and caused them severe nausea, but they believed that this pain was a necessary purification. The following spring, when their sixth child was born, his left arm suddenly bent at the elbow and his right leg bent backwards at the knee.
The deformities were worse than anything Martha had ever seen. His diary for that night contained a brief, almost enigmatic note. They sought a remedy for what was poisoning the earth itself, and the earth responded. Later, Garrett discovered the remains of the potion in Caldwell’s cabin: a bottle labeled “B” and “Sun’s Pharmaccore Remedies Lexington.”
Its ingredients had been banned since the beginning of the century. Modern analyses revealed its composition decades later: lead acetate and digitalis extract, both potentially responsible for Udero’s birth defects. Another tragedy born not of cruelty, but of naïve hope. Two misfits clinging to superstition in a world that had already abandoned them.
Garrett’s frustration came to a head when he realized that academic medicine would not take his findings seriously without direct analysis. He needed an institutional authority to confirm his observations. In December 1896, he wrote directly to Dr. Luellis Barker, a promising scientist at Johns Hopkins University who was known for his questioning of conventional medical ideas.
This letter took a different approach. Garrett acknowledged the impossibility of the case, admitted that he questioned everything he had learned in medical school, and asked direct questions. “Come and see for yourself,” he wrote, “or you will wonder forever if you have missed the most important hereditary case study of the century.” Three months later, a telegram from Barker arrived.
He was coming to Kentucky with a team. While Garrett waited for the arrival of Hopkins’ team, Sarah gave birth to her ninth child in February 1897. The timing was ideal. The baby was born with what the medical team later described as a multi-organ dislocation. His heart was partially located on the right side of his chest, and his liver occupied the space where his stomach should have been.
His intestines were twisted in the opposite direction to normal. Martha’s hands trembled as she cleaned the newborn, aware that the invisible internal chaos was probably much worse than the outward signs suggested. The baby survived the first week, then the first month, thwarting all hopes. However, breastfeeding him required a delicate position to avoid false paths, and he vomited frequently, his malformed digestive system struggling to carry out vital functions.
Sarah, exhausted by nine pregnancies in seven years, had not much milk left. His elders, especially his fourteen-year-old daughter whose spinal sprain had considerably worsened, helped to care for their younger siblings with a skill born of necessity. The Harland Hospital archives, obtained thanks to Garrett’s insistence, record three visits to the emergency room between 1894 and 1896.
The seventh child, born in the fall of 1895, suffered from epileptic seizures so severe that Benjamin’s cousins had to drive the family to the city, an arduous 19-kilometre journey. The attending physician noted that the child had significant developmental delay, limited verbal abilities and a cranial malformation characterized by premature fusion of the cranial sutures, forcing the brain to develop against the rigid bone.
The file of the eighth child revealed something even more troubling. Born on June 18, 1896, he had no left kidney. His right kidney had been enlarged to compensate, but it was not functioning properly. He also suffered from syndactyly in all four limbs: his fingers and toes were intertwined, preventing the proper functioning of each finger.