Skip to content 
The area around Hemmed-in Hollow presented unique challenges for searchers. The river curved sharply through a narrow gorge, with bluffs rising almost vertically on both sides. Side canyons and hollows branched off in multiple directions, many of them filled with thick stands of pine and oak that blocked visibility from helicopters. Limestone caves pocked the cliffs like Swiss cheese, some large enough for a person to enter, most too small to explore without specialized equipment.
Search teams focused their efforts on the water first, then expanded to include the immediate shoreline and lower reaches of the side canyons. Dive teams from the Arkansas State Police worked the deeper pools, their visibility limited by tannic water that turned dark brown where Big Creek fed into the main stem. Side-scan sonar detected several large objects on the river bottom that turned out to be fallen trees and discarded tires from decades past.May be an image of text that says ‘VERY MUCH OCCUPIED’
The weather held for the 1st week, allowing helicopters to provide aerial support and keeping the river at manageable levels for diving operations. But on September 23rd, a late-season thunderstorm swept through the Ozarks, dropping 4 in of rain in 6 hours and turning the Buffalo from a clear mountain stream into a chocolate-colored torrent that made further diving impossible.
“That was when we knew we were probably looking at a recovery, not a rescue,” Wulmack said. “Water like that moves everything. If Marcus had been in the river, that flood would have carried him miles downstream, probably all the way to the White River. We’d find him eventually, but it might take weeks or months.”
The official search was scaled back after 2 weeks, though volunteers continued combing the riverbanks for another month. Marcus’s family offered a $5,000 reward for information leading to the recovery of his body. Flyers with his photograph appeared in gas stations and cafes throughout the Buffalo River region. The Arkansas Game and Fish Commission issued bulletins to guides and outfitters asking them to watch for anything unusual during float trips.
Nothing turned up.
The Buffalo River had apparently swallowed Marcus Holloway completely.
His sister Laya refused to accept the official conclusion of accidental drowning. She drove down from Fayetteville every weekend for 6 months, walking riverbanks and side trails, posting fresh flyers, asking questions that had already been asked dozens of times. She hired a private investigator, a retired state police detective named Ray Fulbright, who specialized in missing-persons cases. Fulbright spent 3 weeks in Newton County interviewing everyone who had seen Marcus that last day, reviewing the physical evidence, studying maps and satellite images of the search area. His conclusion matched the official findings.
Marcus Holloway had likely suffered some kind of medical emergency while kayaking, gone into the water, and drowned. The flood had moved his body beyond recovery.
“I told Laya what I tell all the families in cases like this,” Fulbright said later. “The river is big and it keeps its secrets. Sometimes people just disappear and we never find out exactly what happened. It’s not what anyone wants to hear, but it’s the truth.”
Laya stopped her weekend trips to the Buffalo in March 2023. She kept the reward posted for another year, renewing the flyers twice before finally accepting that her brother was gone. The case remained officially open but inactive, filed among dozens of similar disappearances across Arkansas waterways for nearly 2 years.
That was where the story ended. Marcus Holloway had become another cautionary tale about the dangers of solo river running, another entry in the grim statistics that outdoor recreation enthusiasts prefer not to think about.
Then came the August morning when Kim Porter, hiking with her teenage daughters near Hemmed-in Hollow, noticed something that did not belong wedged in the rocks of a small creek bed about 3 mi downstream from where Marcus’s kayak had been found.
“At first, I thought it was just trash,” Porter said later. “You know how it is. People throw all kinds of stuff in the woods. But when I got closer, I could see it was some kind of camera. One of those action cameras that kayakers and mountain bikers use. The case was cracked, but it looked like it might still work.”
Porter’s daughter, Madison, a college sophomore majoring in digital media, recognized the GoPro immediately and convinced her mother to take it to the authorities rather than simply disposing of it as litter.
“I told her there might be important stuff on the memory card,” Madison said. “I was like, what if someone lost their vacation videos or something?”
Deputy Tessmer, the same officer who had coordinated the initial search for Marcus, was on duty when Porter brought the camera to the Newton County Sheriff’s Office. The serial number on the housing matched Marcus Holloway’s equipment list exactly. The same camera he had been carrying when he disappeared 23 months earlier.