Skip to content 
I climbed up into the musty darkness, pulled the ladder up behind me, found the small metal bolt latch on the inside of the access door exactly where Rachel said it would be, slid it shut, and sat in the pitch-black attic surrounded by storage boxes and old furniture.
I held my phone with the ringer turned off, my whole body trembling, wondering why my FBI agent sister had told me to hide from the man I had loved for five years. I did not have to wait long to understand, because twenty-three minutes later, I heard the front door of my house open.
Our house was a single-story 1920s bungalow. The attic ran directly above the living room, and through a small gap in the floorboards, a crack where two boards did not quite meet, I could see a narrow slice of the room below, lit faintly by the streetlight filtering through the windows.
I watched Marcus come home. But he was not alone. He opened the door and let another man into our house, a man I had never seen before, tall, muscular, dressed in all black, with something metallic in his hand that caught the light.
A weapon. I pressed both hands over my mouth to keep from screaming.
Then I heard my husband’s voice, calm and businesslike, saying words that stopped my heart.
“She should be in the bedroom, second door on the right, asleep. Make it look like a home invasion. Random. Violent. I’ll head to the Marriott downtown with my alibi. You have until 2 a.m.”
The stranger’s voice was rough, flat, emotionless. “Twelve million is a lot of money for one job. I’ll make it clean. Professional. Just like we discussed.”
Marcus handed him something small. Keys.
“Back door key in case you need another exit. Front door will lock automatically when you leave. Remember, it has to look like a burglary gone wrong. A tragedy. Nothing that points to me.”
“I’ve done this sixteen times. I know how to stage a scene. Your wife won’t suffer. Quick. Efficient.”
They both started walking toward the bedroom, toward where I should have been sleeping. Where I would have been sleeping if Rachel had not called.
I sat frozen in the attic, both hands clamped over my mouth, tears streaming silently down my face, watching my husband lead a contract attacker toward the room where he believed I was asleep.
I am so glad you are here with me. Please like this video, listen to my story until the end, and let me know which city you are watching from. That way I can see how far my story has reached.
My name is Claire Elizabeth Mitchell. I am thirty-four years old, a freelance graphic designer, and I need to tell you how I got here, hiding in an attic, watching my husband arrange for me to disappear. It starts with my sister.
Rachel Anne Mitchell is four years older than me. She was born in 1986 in Eugene, Oregon, where our parents were both professors at the University of Oregon. Our father taught philosophy. Our mother taught literature.
I was born in 1990. Rachel was four when I came home from the hospital, and according to family legend, she took one look at me and declared, “That’s my baby. I’m going to protect her forever.”
And she did. Growing up, Rachel was my protector, my defender, my hero.
When I was five and got bullied in kindergarten, eight-year-old Rachel marched up to the bully and told him that if he ever touched me again, he would regret it. He never bothered me again.
When I was ten and struggling with math, fourteen-year-old Rachel spent hours tutoring me, patient and encouraging, never giving up until I understood. When I was sixteen and got my heart broken by my first boyfriend, twenty-year-old Rachel drove home from college, brought me ice cream, and let me cry on her shoulder for three hours.
“Boys are idiots,” she told me. “Someday you’ll find one who isn’t. Until then, you’ve got me.”
Rachel was brilliant. She graduated high school at sixteen, earned a full scholarship to Stanford, and double-majored in psychology and criminal justice. While most kids were going to parties and football games, Rachel was studying criminal behavior, reading case files, and analyzing violent offender patterns.
“I want to understand what makes people do terrible things,” she told me when I visited her at Stanford during my senior year of high school. “If we can understand them, we can catch them, stop them, protect people.”
After Stanford, Rachel applied to the FBI. At twenty-two years old, younger than most candidates, she was accepted to Quantico, graduated at the top of her class, and was assigned to the Behavioral Analysis Unit within three years.
By the time she was thirty, she was one of the FBI’s top profilers, specializing in dangerous repeat offenders and violent predators. She would call me from wherever she was stationed, usually Virginia, where the BAU was based at Quantico, and we would talk for hours.
“How’s the serial predator hunting business?” I would joke.
“Can’t talk about active cases,” she would say. “But I caught a bad guy last week. Got him to confess. He’s going away forever.”
“You’re amazing, Rachel.”
“I’m just doing my job protecting people. Remember what I told you when you were born? That’s my baby. I protect her forever. That goes for a lot of people now, not just you.”
But I was always her priority. Always the baby sister she had sworn to protect. I just never imagined she would have to protect me from my own husband.
I met Marcus Chen in September 2019 at a networking event for creative professionals in Portland. I had moved to Portland after college, earned my graphic design degree from Portland State, graduated in 2013, and spent six years building my freelance business designing logos, websites, and marketing materials for small businesses and startups.
The networking event was at a trendy bar in the Pearl District. I almost did not go. I was tired, had a deadline, and wanted to stay home, but my friend convinced me.
“Claire, you need to get out, meet people, network, maybe meet a guy who isn’t a starving artist for once.”
So I went. Marcus was standing by the bar, talking to another architect about the renovation of some historic building downtown. He was handsome in a polished, professional way, well dressed, confident, about six feet tall, with dark hair and an easy smile.
When the other architect left, Marcus turned and saw me watching.
“Guilty of eavesdropping,” I said. “I love historic renovations. The way old buildings can be transformed while preserving their character.”
He smiled. “A woman after my own heart. I’m Marcus. Marcus Chen.”
“Claire Mitchell. Graphic designer.”
“Design. My favorite subject after architecture. What kind of design?”
We talked for two hours. About design principles, about the intersection of form and function, about Portland’s architecture and art scene, about our careers.
“Most people just see surfaces,” he told me. “But you see meaning, symbolism, the story a design tells. That’s rare.”
When the event ended, he asked for my number.
“I’d really like to take you to dinner,” he said. “A real dinner. Not networking. Just us.”
I gave him my number. Our first date was three days later at a French restaurant in northwest Portland. He picked me up at my apartment, a small one-bedroom in the Hawthorne District, with flowers.
“My mother always said never show up to a date empty-handed.”
Over dinner, we talked about everything. Our childhoods, our families, our dreams.
“I have one older sister,” I told him. “Rachel. She works for the FBI.”
“FBI doing what?”
“Behavioral analysis. Violent crimes. She’s brilliant. Kind of intimidating, honestly.”
Marcus laughed. “Remind me to make a good impression when I meet her.”
“You’re planning to meet her? We just met.”
“I’m planning to see you again and again. And if this goes where I think it might go, eventually I’ll meet your sister, the FBI agent. Better to prepare myself now.”
I liked his confidence, his directness, his focus on me. We dated for eight months. He was attentive without being clingy, romantic without being overwhelming, successful without being arrogant.
He would bring me coffee at my apartment when I was working on tight deadlines, leave little notes in my mailbox, and text me good morning every day.
“You make me want to be a better man,” he told me on our three-month anniversary.
In May 2020, he took me to Cannon Beach for the weekend and rented a beautiful cottage overlooking Haystack Rock. On Saturday evening, we walked on the beach at sunset. The iconic rock formation loomed behind us, waves crashed against the shore, and seabirds called overhead.
Marcus stopped walking and turned to face me.
“Claire, I know we’ve only been together eight months, but I’ve never been more certain of anything in my life. You’re creative, compassionate, brilliant, beautiful. You see the world differently than anyone I’ve ever met. I want to spend my life with you. I want to wake up next to you every morning. I want to build a future with you.”
He got down on one knee in the sand.
“Claire Elizabeth Mitchell, will you marry me?”
The ring was beautiful and simple, a single diamond on a platinum band. I said yes.
We got married in June 2020. It was a small ceremony. COVID had just started shutting everything down, so it was only immediate family. My parents flew in from Eugene. Marcus’s parents came from Seattle. Rachel flew in from Virginia.
She pulled me aside before the ceremony in the small room where I was getting ready.
“Claire, are you absolutely sure about this? You’ve only known him for a year. I’m sure he’s wonderful, but—”
“Rachel, you’ve spent time with him. Don’t you like him?”
She hesitated. “He seems fine. Polished. Successful. Says all the right things. I just want to make sure you’re not rushing into this.”
“I’m not rushing. I love him. He loves me. We’re ready.”
Rachel hugged me tight. “Okay. But promise me something. If anything ever feels wrong, anything at all, you tell me immediately.”
“Promise. Nothing’s going to feel wrong.”
“Promise me anyway.”
“I promise.”
She kissed my forehead. “I love you, baby sister. I just want you to be safe and happy.”
“I am. I will be.”
I wish I had paid more attention to her instincts. Marcus and I moved into a house in Portland’s Alberta Arts District in July 2020. It was a 1920s bungalow with beautiful bones, but it was desperately outdated and needed a complete renovation.
“I’ll do most of the work myself,” Marcus said. “Save money, make it exactly what we want.”
He was talented, really talented. Over the next year, he transformed that house, opening up the walls between the kitchen and living room to create a bright, modern space while preserving the original hardwood floors and crown molding. He updated the bathrooms with subway tile and vintage fixtures that honored the home’s era.
He converted the unfinished basement into a home office for me, with perfect lighting, a built-in desk, and space for all my design equipment.
“This is your creative sanctuary,” he said when it was finished. “Your space to make beautiful things.”
I loved that house. I loved the life we were building. I worked from home, designing for clients across the country. Marcus worked at his architecture firm downtown, occasionally traveling for projects.
Our routine was comfortable, domestic, happy. I would work in my basement office during the day. Marcus would come home around 6 p.m. We would cook dinner together, watch movies, and talk about our days.